What Payroll Software Really Costs: A Worked Example for a 60-Person, Two-Country Team
Base fees and per-employee rates are only part of the bill. We modeled payroll line by line for a hypothetical 60-person company in two countries, for year one and each year after.
Why the per-employee rate is the wrong number to compare
You have two payroll quotes. One says $6 per employee per month, the other says $38. Most buyers compare those two numbers and stop. That's a mistake. In the model below, the per-employee lines make up barely half of the cheaper option's first-year bill.
Payroll software pricing is usually quoted as a base subscription plus a per-employee-per-month (PEPM) charge. The invoice then adds more: implementation, off-cycle runs, year-end filings, joiner and leaver fees, contract minimums, annual price increases, foreign-exchange margins on payroll funding, and the staff hours spent reconciling it all. Some vendors fold most of this into the rate. Others charge for each item. The headline price won't tell you which kind of vendor you're dealing with.
This article builds a full cost model for a hypothetical 60-person company with employees in two countries. It compares two common setups: local providers in each country, or one global payroll platform. Every figure is a typical 2026 market range, or a midpoint from one. Real pricing varies by contract, country, headcount and negotiation, so confirm every line with the vendors you're evaluating.
The hypothetical company: 45 people in the UK, 15 in Poland
We chose the UK and Poland because together they show a common pattern. The headquarters country has a mature, low-cost payroll software market. In the second country, most companies this size use a local bureau or accounting firm. Swap in your own countries. The method stays the same; the numbers won't.
Assumptions behind every figure that follows:
- Headcount: 45 employees in the UK, 15 in Poland. The company has its own legal entity in both, so this is payroll, not employer-of-record.
- Pay frequency: monthly in both countries, so 24 regular runs a year in total.
- Turnover: about 15% a year, or roughly nine leavers and nine joiners. Two leavers and two joiners are in Poland.
- Off-cycle runs: six a year. Four in the UK (a bonus run, corrections, final pay) and two in Poland.
- UK obligations: real-time submissions to the tax authority each run, pension auto-enrolment, year-end employee statements, and benefits-in-kind reporting because the company provides private medical insurance.
- Poland obligations: monthly social insurance contributions and income tax advances, annual employee tax statements, and the employer's annual reconciliation.
- Internal time: $50 an hour, fully loaded, for finance or HR staff.
- Funding: Polish payroll is funded from a GBP account. Total annual employer cost to fund in Poland is about $600,000.
These aren't benchmarks. They're inputs chosen so you can check the arithmetic.
Option A line by line: HQ software plus a local bureau
In Option A the company runs UK payroll in-house on a subscription product (Sage, IRIS, BrightPay and Xero Payroll are among the options) and outsources Polish payroll to a local bureau that handles calculations, filings and payslips. UK software at this tier typically includes off-cycle runs and statutory year-end statements in the subscription. Bureaus typically bill them separately.
| Cost line | Typical 2026 range | Year one | Steady state |
|---|---|---|---|
| UK software base fee | $40–80/month | $600 | $600 |
| UK per-employee fee | $4–8 PEPM | $3,240 (45 × $6 × 12) | $3,240 |
| UK benefits-in-kind / payrolled benefits module | $200–600/year | $400 | $400 |
| UK setup and data migration | $500–2,000 one-off | $1,000 | $0 |
| Poland bureau per-employee fee | $25–40 PEPM, minimum $300–500/month | $5,760 (15 × $32 × 12) | $5,760 |
| Poland onboarding | $1,500–3,000 one-off | $2,000 | $0 |
| Poland off-cycle runs | $75–150 each | $200 (2 × $100) | $200 |
| Poland annual tax statements | $10–20 per form | $255 (17 × $15) | $255 |
| Poland joiner/leaver admin | $15–40 each | $100 (4 × $25) | $100 |
| Internal time: two vendors, reconciliation, ledger mapping | 4–8 hours/month | $3,600 (6 hrs × $50 × 12) | $3,600 |
| Total | $17,155 | $14,155 |
Note the 17 Polish year-end forms, not 15. Employees who left during the year still need an annual statement, and budgets often miss that. The internal-time line is the most debatable figure here. Two vendors means two data formats, two payment calendars and two sets of journal entries, and someone has to merge them into one ledger every month. Six hours is a middle estimate for a 60-person company with a competent finance lead. Count your own.
Option B line by line: one global payroll platform
In Option B both countries run through one global payroll platform. Providers in this category include Deel, Remote, Papaya Global, Rippling, ADP Global Payroll, CloudPay and Activpayroll. Most process payroll in-country through their own entities or partner bureaus, then add a single interface, reporting layer and invoice on top. Pricing models differ widely: some bundle nearly everything into the PEPM, others charge per country, per run or per form.
| Cost line | Typical 2026 range | Year one | Steady state |
|---|---|---|---|
| Per-employee fee, both countries | $30–60 PEPM | $27,360 (60 × $38 × 12) | $27,360 |
| Platform base fee | $0–500/month, often waived above a headcount threshold | $0 | $0 |
| Implementation | $1,500–5,000 per country | $5,000 (2 × $2,500) | $0 |
| Off-cycle runs | $100–250 per run, per country | $900 (6 × $150) | $900 |
| Year-end filings | Often included; $10–30 per form when not | $0 | $0 |
| Joiner/leaver admin | Usually included | $0 | $0 |
| Internal time: one system, consolidated reporting | 1–3 hours/month | $1,200 (2 hrs × $50 × 12) | $1,200 |
| Total | $34,460 | $29,460 |
We assumed the vendor includes year-end forms and joiner/leaver processing. That's common in this category, not universal. If yours charges $20 a form, add about $1,240 a year for the roughly 62 UK and Polish statements. Check implementation scope too. A $2,500-per-country quote usually covers configuration and one parallel run; historical data migration, custom ledger exports and HR system integration are often scoped and billed separately.
First year, steady state and the effective per-employee rate
The number that matters is the effective rate per employee per month: everything you spend in a steady-state year, divided by headcount and by 12.
| Measure | Option A: local stack | Option B: global platform | Gap |
|---|---|---|---|
| First-year total | $17,155 | $34,460 | $17,305 |
| Steady-state annual total | $14,155 | $29,460 | $15,305 |
| Effective cost per employee per month (steady state) | $19.66 | $40.92 | $21.26 |
| Three-year total, no price increases | $45,465 | $93,380 | $47,915 |
The local stack's effective rate of about $20 is more than three times its headline UK rate of $6. The global platform's effective rate of about $41 sits close to its headline $38. That's the central finding. Bundled platforms look expensive on the quote but rarely surprise you on the invoice. Local stacks look cheap on the quote and accumulate cost through implementation, bureau extras and internal time.
Still, for this company Option A is clearly cheaper and, in our view, the better choice. The UK software market is mature and inexpensive. Fifteen employees comfortably clears a Polish bureau's minimum. And a finance lead who already reconciles UK payroll can absorb a second vendor. Paying roughly $15,000 a year more for one login and consolidated reporting is hard to justify at this size and spread.
That verdict holds only for these assumptions. The next two sections show which ones would overturn it.
The cost lines that move the total most
We varied each assumption in turn. Four lines moved the totals far more than the rest.
Off-cycle runs
Six a year suits a company with steady salaries. A sales-heavy team paying commissions outside the main run, or a company that runs frequent corrections, could easily hit 24. At $150 a run under Option B, that's $3,600 a year instead of $900, while most UK software would charge nothing extra. Count your off-cycle runs from the last 12 months before comparing quotes.
Year-end and statutory forms
Year-end statements, benefits reporting, amended filings and annual reconciliations sometimes sit in contracts as "additional services." A vendor charging per form and per amendment can add $1,000–3,000 a year at this headcount. Ask each vendor for the full list of year-end outputs in each country and which are included.
Minimum fees
Minimums dominate at low headcount. If the Polish team shrank to eight people, the per-employee fee would come to $256 a month, but a $400 minimum would apply instead. That's $4,800 a year, an effective $50 per employee per month before extras. Minimums are the main reason local stacks lose their price advantage in small satellite offices.
Foreign-exchange margin on payroll funding
This one never appears on the payroll invoice, which is why it's missed. Funding $600,000 a year of Polish payroll from a GBP account costs about $3,000 for every half-point of FX spread. Some global platforms require you to fund through them at their own conversion rate; others let you fund locally. With a local stack, you convert through your bank or a payments provider. Ask every vendor whether they take a margin on funding and how much. At this volume, it can exceed the entire off-cycle budget.
Annual price increases compound as well. A 7% yearly uplift raises Option B's year-three subscription by about $4,000. Negotiate a cap before you sign, not at renewal.
Where the math flips toward a global platform
Option A won because the company has solid headcount in each country and cheap software at HQ. Change either condition and the gap narrows fast.
A third country with a small team. Say the same company hires five people in Singapore or Mexico. A local bureau with a $300–500 monthly minimum and $1,500–3,000 setup costs $5,100–9,000 in year one, then $3,600–6,000 a year: $60–100 per employee per month. Adding those five to the global platform at $38 PEPM costs $2,280 a year plus roughly $2,500 to implement. Small teams scattered across several countries are where global platforms compare best against local providers.
Thin in-house payroll expertise. Option A assumes someone at HQ can check a foreign bureau's output, spot a wrong social-insurance rate and push back. Without that person, the real exposure isn't internal time; it's errors nobody catches. Penalty regimes vary widely by country, so have an experienced payroll professional or local adviser assess that risk.
Consolidated reporting requirements. If your board, investors or auditors want headcount, gross-to-net and employer cost in one format across countries, a platform saves hours our model only partly captures.
Which country is second. This shifts the result more than most buyers expect. In India, local bureau fees are often well below $15 PEPM, so a local stack wins by an even wider margin. In Brazil or France, statutory complexity tends to push local bureau pricing toward $40–80 PEPM, and the gap largely disappears. In the UAE, mainland employers generally must pay salaries through the Wage Protection System (free-zone rules vary), so confirm any provider can produce compliant salary files.
Without an entity in the second country, this comparison doesn't apply. Employer-of-record services commonly run $400–1,000 per employee per month, and that's a separate decision.
How to build your own model and which contract terms to price first
This takes an afternoon with a spreadsheet and your last 12 months of payroll records:
- List headcount by country, pay frequency in each, and expected joiners and leavers.
- Count last year's off-cycle runs by country, and judge whether next year will bring more.
- List every statutory year-end output in each country. Ask each vendor, in writing, which are included in the base price.
- Get minimum fees, implementation scope, price-increase caps, notice periods and exit or data-export fees in writing.
- Ask how payroll is funded and what FX spread applies, then price it at your actual annual funding volume.
- Estimate monthly internal hours for each option at your team's real rate.
- Calculate first-year, steady-state and three-year totals, plus the effective per-employee rate, for each option.
In contract review, put a price on each of these before you sign:
- Implementation quoted "from" a figure, with no defined scope or number of parallel runs.
- Off-cycle runs covered by "fair use" with no stated number.
- Year-end, amendments or benefits reporting listed as "additional services" without a rate card.
- Auto-renewal with uncapped price increases, or caps above roughly 7%.
- Fees to export your payroll history when you leave.
- A global platform that won't name its in-country partner, or that caps liability for filing errors at one month's fees.
The decision rule we'd apply at this size: with at least 10–15 employees in each country and a capable local market in each, start with local providers. In our model they cost about half as much, and that pattern tends to hold whenever headcount comfortably clears bureau minimums. Re-price a global platform when you add a country with fewer than about 10 people, or when vendor management takes more than a day a month. Either way, have a qualified payroll or tax professional in each country confirm compliance scope before you sign.
Frequently asked questions
What is a typical per-employee payroll fee in 2026?
It depends on the delivery model and country. Self-service payroll software for small businesses in mature markets usually costs about $4–12 PEPM plus a modest base fee. Local bureaus often charge $25–40 PEPM with monthly minimums, and multi-country platforms typically charge $30–60 PEPM. These are typical 2026 market ranges that vary by contract and region, so confirm current pricing with each vendor.
How much does payroll implementation cost for a company of 50–100 people?
Anywhere from about $500 for a single-country software setup to $1,500–5,000 per country for a bureau or global platform. Scope drives the figure: data migration, number of parallel runs, ledger and HR system integrations, and whether historical year-to-date figures are loaded. Ask for a written scope, because "from" pricing often leaves out the work that takes longest.
Are year-end filings usually included in payroll software pricing?
Often, but not always. Domestic payroll software in many countries includes statutory year-end employee statements in the subscription. Bureaus and some global platforms charge per form, per amendment or per annual reconciliation. Get a list of every year-end output for each country and have the vendor confirm in writing which are covered.
Is global payroll cheaper than using a local provider in each country?
Usually not when you have solid headcount in each of a few countries, because local software and bureaus cost less per head. Global platforms tend to win with small teams in several countries, where local bureau minimums can push the effective per-employee cost to $60–100 or more. Model both options with your real headcount by country rather than relying on rules of thumb.
What counts as an off-cycle payroll run, and why do vendors charge for it?
An off-cycle run is any payment processed outside the regular schedule: a bonus, a correction, a leaver's final pay or a missed overtime payment. Each can require fresh calculations, statutory submissions and funding, which is why bureaus and platforms often charge roughly $75–250 per run. If your team pays commissions or makes frequent corrections, this line can grow faster than any other.
Should a small business choose payroll software or an outsourced provider?
If someone in-house understands local payroll rules and can check the output, software is usually cheaper in your home country. Outsourcing makes more sense where you lack that expertise, the rules are complex, or headcount is too small to justify building internal knowledge. Many companies of 50–100 people use both: software at headquarters and a bureau or platform elsewhere. A local payroll or tax professional can confirm which obligations apply in each country.
Written by the Medicaldesk Pro editorial team. Prices, features and rules change often - confirm details with the vendor or a licensed professional before you decide.